A strong CV gets someone through the door. It rarely tells you whether they will thrive once they are inside.
Most hiring managers have lived both sides of this: the candidate who looked perfect on paper but struggled in the role, and the one who seemed an outside chance but quickly became indispensable.
Hiring is hard enough already. In the March quarter 2026, 45% of recruiting employers in Australia reported difficulty filling roles (Jobs and Skills Australia, REOS). When every hire takes that much effort, it pays to look beyond keywords and job titles.
The four things that matter most
- Capability. Can they actually do the work, not just describe it? Look for evidence of outcomes rather than lists of tools.
- Experience. Has their experience built judgement? Ten years can mean ten years of growth, or one year repeated ten times.
- Emotional intelligence. How do they handle pressure, feedback and difficult stakeholders?
- Alignment. Do their values, ways of working and ambitions fit the team and where the role is heading?
Skills tell part of the story. How someone behaves under pressure tells the rest.
Quick check: is your hiring process testing the right things?
Answer these honestly:
- Does our interview test how someone would handle a real problem from this role?
- Have we defined what success looks like at six and twelve months?
- Do we hear from the people the new hire will work alongside?
- Could we tell the difference between confidence and capability?
If you answered “not really” to two or more, your process may be rewarding presentation rather than performance.
Practical ways to look beyond the CV
- Use scenario questions drawn from real work in the role.
- Ask about a setback and what changed afterwards.
- Involve a future peer, not just the hiring manager.
- Weigh learning agility alongside current skills, especially in fast-moving technology roles.
Key takeaways
- A CV shows history. Great hiring looks for capability, judgement and fit.
- Define success before you interview, not after.
- Test behaviour with real scenarios, not hypothetical questions.
Hiring for a role where getting it right really matters? Submit a requirement and let’s talk about the capability you need.
Disclaimer: This article reflects AveniQ Enterprise’s perspective and is provided for general information only. Statistics are sourced from third parties, such as the ABS, Jobs and Skills Australia and the ACS, as published at October 2026, and may since have been revised. No warranty is given as to their accuracy or completeness, and nothing here constitutes professional advice. Please refer to the original sources before relying on any figure.
Have a question about this insight?
We’d love to hear your thoughts. Send us a general enquiry and our team will be in touch.